| Holy Texts & Dogma What's with all these books that people bet their lives on? This forum is all about dogma and reasons for circular arguments. |
Want These Ads To Go Away? Become A Premium Member. Click here to see how...
Bookmark this thread at ThreadSoup:
Add it! |
05-28-2008, 10:07 AM
|
#261 (permalink)
| | Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 60
| Quote:
Originally Posted by jaej You have no way of knowing these errors are as trivial as you claim. Sure, it could be just some bad grammar, but it could also be something much more dramatic. The point is, son, the book you claim as the perfect work of god is clearly a fallible work of man; not only is the content not literally true, it can't even be translated accurately. | ____________
Noetic
No further comments over paternalistic remarks that show no scholarship from a determined antagonist who apparently has not and will not review the Book from cover to cover before critiquing. |
| |
05-28-2008, 10:20 AM
|
#262 (permalink)
| | Senior Member
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 829
| Noetic, unlike you, I have a real job and a real set of commitments which make real world demands on my time.
I have little time to gather actual evidence and present in the way you seem to want things done.
But. The evidence remains that there was little in the way of "divine guidance" in the creation of the bible.
__________________ Religion: The ultimate definition of verisimilitude |
| |
08-18-2008, 02:22 AM
|
#263 (permalink)
| | Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 14
| if you believe there is no God, then how can you go on in life believing that your life as it is right now was all assembled in a matter of a Few million ( billion gizillion years ? )
have you not looked at your hands , your face , your legs , arms , muscles , veins ..... etc
then ask yourself .... chaos < order ?
i choose not to believe that little tiny organisms "evolve" if you give them enough time.
time does not replace the intelligent design.
intelligence > time
and what gives these little things the will power to "want" to get better.. the fact that there tired of living in a pool of muck?
why are they tired?
why do they want to get better ?
this question really goes out to evolutionists / anyone
thanks |
| |
08-18-2008, 03:06 AM
|
#264 (permalink)
| | Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Winnipeg, Canada
Posts: 427
| Quote:
Originally Posted by imachristian if you believe there is no God, then how can you go on in life believing that your life as it is right now was all assembled in a matter of a Few million (billion gizillion years ? | How can I go on in life? Rather easily, in fact. My dance card is quite full, with lots of interesting things to do.
Is there something magical about being *poofed* into existence by a mythical being? Some otherworldly "meaning" that we can only get second-hand from a god?
I. Think. Not.
We make our own meaning in every moment of our lives. And then our molecules get recycled into other forms and we "live" as a never-ending, always-changing aggregation of matter and energy... The real eternal life. Quote: |
i choose not to believe that little tiny organisms "evolve" if you give them enough time.
| How very unfortunate for you. Evolution is a reality -- My own brother regularly observes it happening in his research. Only the explanation is a theory.
(A scientific theory, by the way, is not a wild guess; it's a prediction of future results based on careful observations of existing data. Theories are occasionally amended to reflect new discoveries, and sometimes they are replaced by newer theories that serve as better explanations. The data itself does not change; it just gets a better explanation.) Quote: |
time does not replace the intelligent design.
| Unsupported assertion. There is no evidence for "intelligent design" and no evidence for a designer.
There are, however, copious examples of spectacularly unintelligent design, such as the human body using a common passageway for air and food (resulting in death from asphyxiation). Quote: |
and what gives these little things the will power to "want" to get better.. the fact that there tired of living in a pool of muck?
| There is no "want" or willpower driving evolution. None. Zero. It is a chemical process linked inexorably to environmental pressures and expressed through reproductive success over many generations.
In any group of organisms, there will be variations. Most of them result from the combination of chromosomes from the male and female parents, but the immediate chemical environment and the strength or weakness of molecular bonds will occasionally result in a random change in a section of the genetic information.
If a change improves an animal's survival (for example, by making its claws grow slightly longer and enabling it to kill more prey), that organism will have a better chance of surviving long enough to reproduce. If a change is survival-neutral, it may not be noticed but could still get carried as part of the animal's genetic "recipe". If a change makes it harder for the animal to survive, its population will tend to drop and it may even become extinct.
Please, please put your religious biases aside long enough to read a reputable book on evolutionary science. |
| |
08-18-2008, 09:42 AM
|
#265 (permalink)
| | Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 60
| Quote:
Originally Posted by Astreja Quote:
Originally Posted by imachristian if you believe there is no God, then how can you go on in life believing that your life as it is right now was all assembled in a matter of a Few million (billion gizillion years ? | How can I go on in life? Rather easily, in fact. My dance card is quite full, with lots of interesting things to do.
Is there something magical about being *poofed* into existence by a mythical being? Some otherworldly "meaning" that we can only get second-hand from a god?
I. Think. Not.
We make our own meaning in every moment of our lives. And then our molecules get recycled into other forms and we "live" as a never-ending, always-changing aggregation of matter and energy... The real eternal life. Quote: |
i choose not to believe that little tiny organisms "evolve" if you give them enough time.
| How very unfortunate for you. Evolution is a reality -- My own brother regularly observes it happening in his research. Only the explanation is a theory.
(A scientific theory, by the way, is not a wild guess; it's a prediction of future results based on careful observations of existing data. Theories are occasionally amended to reflect new discoveries, and sometimes they are replaced by newer theories that serve as better explanations. The data itself does not change; it just gets a better explanation.) Quote: |
time does not replace the intelligent design.
| Unsupported assertion. There is no evidence for "intelligent design" and no evidence for a designer.
There are, however, copious examples of spectacularly unintelligent design, such as the human body using a common passageway for air and food (resulting in death from asphyxiation). Quote: |
and what gives these little things the will power to "want" to get better.. the fact that there tired of living in a pool of muck?
| There is no "want" or willpower driving evolution. None. Zero. It is a chemical process linked inexorably to environmental pressures and expressed through reproductive success over many generations.
In any group of organisms, there will be variations. Most of them result from the combination of chromosomes from the male and female parents, but the immediate chemical environment and the strength or weakness of molecular bonds will occasionally result in a random change in a section of the genetic information.
If a change improves an animal's survival (for example, by making its claws grow slightly longer and enabling it to kill more prey), that organism will have a better chance of surviving long enough to reproduce. If a change is survival-neutral, it may not be noticed but could still get carried as part of the animal's genetic "recipe". If a change makes it harder for the animal to survive, its population will tend to drop and it may even become extinct.
Please, please put your religious biases aside long enough to read a reputable book on evolutionary science. | Noetic defense: Rather set aside your hostilities and do some mature impassionate reasoning. You seem to be conflating self-existence (uncaused) with existence (caused). Why should change 'improve' an animal's survival capabilities? Is that a law of nature? Why can't there be a law which is antithetical to it? Why should any animal survive? Is that a natural imperative? If so, why should there be death and decay? Entropy is the natural law. Death is entropy. If matter has an uncaused existence, then why should it change? Has it no natural right to remain as matter?
How can you 'believe' that anything must change for the better and not for the worse, or survive without having a 'directional' vector. The real 'descent' is from a higher order to a lower order. Why don't you 'believe' that what you are now is a lower order of what you once were in your ancestry? You have to solve the problem of BEING before the problem of BECOMING (change).
Noetic |
| |
08-18-2008, 07:47 PM
|
#266 (permalink)
| | Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 14
| Quote:
How can I go on in life? Rather easily, in fact. My dance card is quite full, with lots of interesting things to do.
Is there something magical about being *poofed* into existence by a mythical being? Some otherworldly "meaning" that we can only get second-hand from a god?
I. Think. Not.
We make our own meaning in every moment of our lives. And then our molecules get recycled into other forms and we "live" as a never-ending, always-changing aggregation of matter and energy... The real eternal life.
| alright , thats your perspective of life Quote:
How very unfortunate for you. Evolution is a reality -- My own brother regularly observes it happening in his research. Only the explanation is a theory.
(A scientific theory, by the way, is not a wild guess; it's a prediction of future results based on careful observations of existing data. Theories are occasionally amended to reflect new discoveries, and sometimes they are replaced by newer theories that serve as better explanations. The data itself does not change; it just gets a better explanation.)
| tell your bro to snap a few pictures when he sees a few missing links =) Quote:
Unsupported assertion. There is no evidence for "intelligent design" and no evidence for a designer.
There are, however, copious examples of spectacularly unintelligent design, such as the human body using a common passageway for air and food (resulting in death from asphyxiation).
| unsupported? what the fact that your brain tells you not to in hail while eating? -your ganna have to give me a better example than that. Quote:
There is no "want" or willpower driving evolution. None. Zero. It is a chemical process linked inexorably to environmental pressures and expressed through reproductive success over many generations.
In any group of organisms, there will be variations. Most of them result from the combination of chromosomes from the male and female parents, but the immediate chemical environment and the strength or weakness of molecular bonds will occasionally result in a random change in a section of the genetic information.
If a change improves an animal's survival (for example, by making its claws grow slightly longer and enabling it to kill more prey), that organism will have a better chance of surviving long enough to reproduce. If a change is survival-neutral, it may not be noticed but could still get carried as part of the animal's genetic "recipe". If a change makes it harder for the animal to survive, its population will tend to drop and it may even become extinct.
Please, please put your religious biases aside long enough to read a reputable book on evolutionary science.
| tell me how the little tiny tiny tiny organisms got there in the first place.
and i believe in adaptation, yes i do... such as if the sun is bright peoples skin in certain areas over time will grow to be darker....
and besides my religious "bias" its only logical that choas cannot turn into order due to time.
chaos + time = order?
not to even mention plants and the earth..... |
| |
08-18-2008, 08:00 PM
|
#267 (permalink)
| | Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: BC Canada, near the US border
Posts: 1,343
| Quote:
Originally Posted by imachristian tell me how the little tiny tiny tiny organisms got there in the first place. | science does not have a "theory" for this yet, but then again neither do you. Quote:
Originally Posted by imachristian and i believe in adaptation, yes i do... such as if the sun is bright peoples skin in certain areas over time will grow to be darker.... | good you believe in evolution. Quote:
Originally Posted by imachristian and besides my religious "bias" its only logical that choas cannot turn into order due to time.
chaos + time = order? | how about "chaos + time + energy = order" ?
there I can give many every day examples eg electrolysis of a copper sulphate solution to make crystalline copper?
__________________ There is a theory which states that if ever anybody discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable. There is another theory which states that this has already happened. ........... Douglas Adams |
| |
08-18-2008, 08:40 PM
|
#268 (permalink)
| | Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 14
| Quote: |
science does not have a "theory" for this yet, but then again neither do you.
| genesis 1:1 Quote: |
good you believe in evolution.
| no i believe in adaptation. there is a difference Quote:
how about "chaos + time + energy = order" ?
there I can give many every day examples eg electrolysis of a copper sulphate solution to make crystalline copper?
| you can add energy.... ya sure - let me know the next time you see the wind create a airplane |
| |
08-18-2008, 08:42 PM
|
#269 (permalink)
| | Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 14
| ill be back tomorrow to respond to anything else
thanks  |
| |
08-18-2008, 08:52 PM
|
#270 (permalink)
| | Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: BC Canada, near the US border
Posts: 1,343
| Quote:
Originally Posted by imachristian Quote: |
science does not have a "theory" for this yet, but then again neither do you.
| 1) genesis 1:1 Quote: |
good you believe in evolution.
| 2) no i believe in adaptation. there is a difference Quote:
how about "chaos + time + energy = order" ?
there I can give many every day examples eg electrolysis of a copper sulphate solution to make crystalline copper?
| 3) you can add energy.... ya sure - let me know the next time you see the wind create a airplane | 1) what are the testable predictions from this theory?
2) could you explain the difference?
3) this is not the way evolution works, a better analogy would be factories forever building prototypes.
You obviously are not a scientist by training?
__________________ There is a theory which states that if ever anybody discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable. There is another theory which states that this has already happened. ........... Douglas Adams |
| | | Thread Tools | | | | Display Modes | Linear Mode |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | | |