Thread: Proving things.
View Single Post
Old 02-15-2008, 09:32 AM   #42 (permalink)
Herra1
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Finland
Posts: 43
Herra1 is on a distinguished road
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Og View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Herra1 View Post
So what do You think, can we ever understand the number 1 ?
Or is it like infinity ?
Too abstract to get hold of ? Me, i tend to think so.
Because im really facinated by what Newton did.
Showed that these abstractions that we draw and think, the world somehow corresponds or have relationship to them.
What do you mean by "understand" then?

The abstractions that we draw and think do not correspond to anything. They are internal representations of external concepts. Math is a pattern of neurons in our brain that helps us interact with the physical world.

The number 1 is just like a "spell checker" in a word processor. It isn't a real thing. A "spell checker" is a complex pattern of electrons in hardware and photons on the screen. It's not a "thing" any more than "1" or "calculus" is a thing.

I don't think you're using the term "understand" in a commonly defined sense.
What i mean as understanding ?
That is a big one.
If i understand something i can control it.
But it dosent mean, that as an example, if i control a car by driving it, that i could build or do something else, other than, put more gasoline in it.
And even my driving, is way off, compared to someone who is better driver.
But yes i understand/ i do have knowledge of driving, and some basic understanding/knowledge bout a car, (new gear, more gas, brakes, wheels are empty).
Do i understand myself ?
Sometimes. BTW i exist, You exist,they exist.

There is only one planet called Venus in our solar system.
It is unique.
There is no other like it.
They say that it exist.

A word is not a real thing. Or have You met one lately ?
Words, in itself, dont correspond to anything either.
But we use them.

I am NOT bringing any gods or deities here, but if You say that when asked,
"pattern of neurons in our brain".
That its just like the one airoplane builder who build a plane, and when they flew it, the plane shaked violently when turned left.
Now, why ?
Well, it is, because of the materials used when he build the plane.
Herra1 is offline   Reply With Quote