View Single Post
Old 01-12-2008, 03:03 AM   #12 (permalink)
tommi atkins
Member
 
tommi atkins's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 80
tommi atkins is on a distinguished road
Default

Historical texts have more direct resources availible to them, and indeed all modern texts will be referencing them.
Writing about the battle of Zama, a Roman could talk with the soldiers there, with the returning army, take accounts from them and with a certain flourish and spin, present the account as trufax.

200 years afterwards, a Carthaginian could draw upon a few surviving documents and come up with the basic fact that they were defeated, yet it was a hard struggle and that the main reason for the defeat was treachery.

2300 years later, to write a fresh account on Zama, a historian will draw on all the old histories ,be severly lacking in many of the original material and simply cobble together their best effort along their original bias.

In a nutshell, and rather neatly, nobody really knows the trufax on anything.
tommi atkins is offline   Reply With Quote