Thread: The Fall of Man
View Single Post
Old 01-08-2008, 08:21 PM   #12 (permalink)
nkrummy
Member
 
nkrummy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: on the east coast, originally west coast
Posts: 38
nkrummy is on a distinguished road
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Skepticologist View Post
If there was a fall of man, which I seriously doubt, it was brought about by the propensities with which god (whom I seriously doubt, at least in a christian context) created him.

It's like a supreme being, who is referred to as god, brought inferior beings, referred to as humans, into existence with a predisposition to behave in ways he deplored. And when they behaved in ways consistent with how he created them, he banished them from the garden and, even worse, under the christian dispensation, sentenced them to an eternity of untold torment.

The christian response to such an assertion involves free will, i.e. god set you up to fail, but you can still choose to succeed against overwhelming odds, if only you summon the will, from somewhere within your god-induced depraved self, to do so.
I think this covers it pretty well- great post!

Of course, the other part to this is where God even places the forbidden tree in the garden and plants a snake there to entice Adam and Eve into disobeying him. Apparantly the "fall of man" was this God's intention all along.
nkrummy is offline   Reply With Quote