Agnostic Forums - View Single Post - Definition of an Agnostic. Just so we're clear...

Piglet · 12-07-2006, 05:15 PM

PS

Piglet IS a true agnostic.
The 'concept of god' is just that.
One cannot prove or disprove a concept about a 'real' thing
without phenomenological support.
One cannot prove a thing exists or does not by talking about it.

In a reality 28 billion light years accross
We humans that have hardly even left out little rock.
cannot claim any phenomenological support to any concept
of 'a god'
'GOD' may be hanging out in the Hercules Cluster and how would we
know it?
We cant.. we are TOO PRIMATIVE
Does a monkey in a tree in zaire know what New york is and that it has a mayor?
It may wonder in its primate way 'why things happen' thus the concept of god is valid.

Admit it.. We RE TOO IGNORANT TO CLAIM UNDERSTANDING of anything outside our rock.
Thus the ONLY LOGICAL POSITION is agnosticism.
Piglet

12-07-2006, 05:15 PM	#30 (permalink)
Piglet Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2006 Posts: 108	PS Piglet IS a true agnostic. The 'concept of god' is just that. One cannot prove or disprove a concept about a 'real' thing without phenomenological support. One cannot prove a thing exists or does not by talking about it. In a reality 28 billion light years accross We humans that have hardly even left out little rock. cannot claim any phenomenological support to any concept of 'a god' 'GOD' may be hanging out in the Hercules Cluster and how would we know it? We cant.. we are TOO PRIMATIVE Does a monkey in a tree in zaire know what New york is and that it has a mayor? It may wonder in its primate way 'why things happen' thus the concept of god is valid. Admit it.. We RE TOO IGNORANT TO CLAIM UNDERSTANDING of anything outside our rock. Thus the ONLY LOGICAL POSITION is agnosticism. Piglet __________________ Vir prudens non contra ventum mingit Last edited by Piglet : 12-07-2006 at 05:29 PM.